Contact us

Earnings Guidance Policy After Form 10-S

Investor Relations 11/16/2026

If Quarterly Filing Becomes Optional, Your Earnings Guidance Policy Becomes the Signal

New research suggests investors read your earnings guidance policy as a forecast of the quiet quarters ahead. Companies that guide only annually fell behind each time optional reporting looked more likely.

If you plan to elect semiannual filing, set your earnings guidance policy for the quarters in between first, then announce both together. A new Boston University study suggests why the sequence matters. Companies guiding only annually trailed quarterly guiders by about 100 basis points, on average, across three steps toward optional reporting. In other words, investors began pricing each company’s likely disclosure habits long before any rule was final.

Why does your earnings guidance policy matter before the rule is final?

Your guidance history matters now because the market started reading it the moment optional reporting looked real. The study, by Francois Brochet and Sabiha Moonmoon, tracked three moments. First, President Trump called for semiannual reporting on September 15, 2025. Then the Wall Street Journal reported in March 2026 that the SEC was preparing a proposal. Finally, the SEC formally proposed optional semiannual reporting on May 5, 2026.

Under that proposal, a company could file one Form 10-S for the first half of its fiscal year instead of 10-Qs. As of November 13, 2026, the SEC’s rulemaking page still lists it as a proposed rule. However, your past earnings guidance policy is already doing the talking for you.

What did investors actually price when semiannual reporting looked likely?

Investors marked down annual-only guiders relative to quarterly guiders, by roughly one percentage point on average per event. The authors compared 275 companies with a quarterly EPS guidance habit against 292 that guided only annually. Quarterly guiders had issued guidance in at least five of the prior eight quarters. Across the three events, the gap added up to about three percentage points of cumulative underperformance.

The result also held up under pressure. For example, the gap was negative at every event and survived alternative definitions and return windows. The authors also reran the test on more than 53,000 combinations of random dates. Only 0.3 percent produced a gap as negative as the real one. The two groups were similar in size and institutional ownership, and the authors controlled for the ways they differed, such as analyst coverage and earnings volatility.

The authors are careful about what this means. Because the rule is not in effect, the returns reflect expectations, not observed behavior. Investors may have been guessing who would elect semiannual filing, or how much each company would still disclose. The study does not separate those channels.

Does an annual-only earnings guidance policy put you at a disadvantage?

In this sample, investors did treat annual-only guidance policies less favorably. Still, the answer is not automatically to start issuing quarterly numbers. The same paper found a second pattern. After controlling for cadence, each additional guided metric was associated with returns about 24 basis points higher.

Our reading goes beyond the paper: an earnings guidance policy seems to earn credit for both predictability and breadth. That suggests a practical option for annual guiders. You can widen what you commit to, such as segment drivers, margin ranges, or the KPIs analysts already model. Then you can pair that breadth with a fixed calendar of updates.

Should you keep quarterly earnings calls and guidance if you file a 10-S?

In our view, most companies that elect semiannual filing should plan to keep quarterly calls, at least through the first cycle. The paper notes that a few corporate commenters told the SEC they might file a 10-S and keep communicating quarterly. However, the authors caution that those letters are self-selected and say little about companies in general. Wachtell, Lipton attorneys pointed to a European precedent on the Harvard Law School Forum on Corporate Governance. After the EU and UK dropped the requirement, many large multinationals kept some quarterly reporting because investors asked for it.

So the real decision is what fills the quarter you no longer file. For instance, that could be a short trading update, a KPI release, or a call that stays on the calendar. We covered how engagement thins out when filings do in an earlier post, and the same logic applies here.

When and how should you announce a new guidance policy?

Announce the reporting election and the guidance policy together, in one place, before the first quarter without a filing. The authors suggest something close to this. Clearly communicating your intended reporting frequency and disclosure commitments could help investors judge what to expect.

Under the proposal, companies would make the election each year by checking a box on the Form 10-K cover. That makes the year-end release and call the natural moment to explain the change. Still, a checkbox on a cover page explains nothing on its own. So treat the change as a planned announcement, reviewed by counsel for Regulation FD. Give it the care you give an earnings call script.

What do companies get wrong about guidance policy during the switch?

The most common mistake is treating the election as a filing decision and the communication as an afterthought. Finance and legal often settle the 10-S question, and IR inherits the explanation weeks later.

A second mistake is announcing the filing change and staying quiet on guidance. Silence on your earnings guidance policy leaves investors to fill the gap with your history. That is exactly what this study measured. A third mistake is assuming the quiet quarter means nothing to produce. In practice, it is the quarter where your credibility depends most on what you have already built.

What do sophisticated companies build instead?

Sophisticated companies write one cadence statement and build every investor touchpoint around it. Start with a working document we call the cadence sheet, which answers the questions below in plain language.

QuestionWhat the cadence sheet records
What do we file?10-Q or 10-S, and when we will revisit the election
What do we release?Earnings releases or trading updates, and their dates
When do we speak?Calls, webcasts, and conference appearances by quarter
What do we guide?Horizon, metrics, and how ranges get updated
Where does it live?The IR site page, the deck slide, and the release language

After that, carry the statement into every format investors see. That usually means a “How we report” page on the IR site and one slide in the investor presentation. It often includes a short CFO video that explains the reasoning in the executive’s own words. Each piece tells the same story, so no investor has to assemble the policy from footnotes. Our investor relations content team builds this kit with companies, scaled to the size of the change.

Frequently asked questions

How much did annual-only guiders lose in the study?

Annual-only guiders earned two-day market-adjusted returns about 100 basis points below quarterly guiders around each of three events. Across all three, that adds up to roughly three percentage points of cumulative underperformance. The gap was negative at every event. It also held under alternative definitions, return windows, and controls for size, coverage, ownership, volatility, and R&D intensity.

Does the study prove that quarterly guidance raises valuation?

No. The authors measure how investors reacted to the possibility of optional reporting, not what happens after companies change their behavior. Investors may have expected annual-only guiders to elect semiannual filing or to disclose less between filings. The paper does not separate those explanations, so treat it as evidence about expectations.

Which companies does this guidance research cover?

The sample covers U.S. companies with established EPS guidance practices and share prices of at least five dollars. That design skews toward larger companies. The result also held after excluding unevenly split industries, including pharmaceuticals, where annual-only guidance is common. Smaller companies without a guidance history fall outside the main comparison.

Should we wait for a final semiannual rule before setting policy?

No. Investors have already reacted to the possibility, so your guidance record is being read today. The SEC proposed the rule on May 5, 2026, and comments closed on July 6, 2026. As of November 13, 2026, the SEC’s rulemaking page still listed it as a proposed rule. Setting your earnings guidance policy now lets you announce it on your terms when a final rule arrives.

The takeaway

If your board is weighing a 10-S election, put the guidance policy on the same agenda. Decide the filing and the guidance policy in the same meeting, and write the cadence sheet before either one is announced. Do you already know what your investors will hear from you in the quarter you stop filing?

Ready to Launch?

Thanks for reaching out!

Strategic depth. Creative excellence. Flawless execution.

Cardboard Spaceship delivers all three — because when your message can’t afford a weak link, you need a partner who doesn’t have one.

Let’s get started.

Strategic depth. Creative excellence. Flawless execution.

Cardboard Spaceship delivers all three — because when your message can’t afford a weak link, you need a partner who doesn’t have one

    • Corporate
    • Commercial
    • Custom Licensed Footage
    • Email
    • Event
    • Facebook
    • Google
    • Instagram
    • LinkedIn
    • Referral
    • YouTube
    • ChatGPT
    • Word of Mouth
    • Other

    On this page